When a craving hits for something sweet, creamy, and irresistibly chocolatey, an Oreo milkshake always delivers. This article walks you through how to make an indulgent Oreo milkshake with just a few ingredients—and even how to make it with only two! We’ll explore what makes this shake so iconic, compare it to popular fast food versions like Chick-fil-A’s, and answer the most common questions home cooks have. Whether you’re looking for a treat to share or a late-night delight, this guide has everything. Let’s dive into the blend of childhood nostalgia and rich flavor that makes the Oreo milkshake a favorite.
Table of Contents
The Story & Origins of the Oreo Milkshake
A childhood craving turned classic comfort
Growing up in the Bavarian countryside, milkshakes weren’t something we had every day. But every now and then, my mom would let me crush some cookies into our homemade vanilla ice cream. The first time I tried that combo with Oreos—brought over from my cousin in the U.S.—it changed everything. Years later, in my Portland kitchen, I recreated that magic with a blender and a bit of cream, and it instantly became one of my most requested treats. This Oreo milkshake recipe brings that same feeling: effortless indulgence you can whip up any time. Whether you’re making it for guests or sipping solo, this shake delivers.
Why Oreo milkshakes never go out of style
What sets the Oreo milkshake apart from other desserts? It’s the nostalgic crunch-meets-creamy texture, the bold cocoa flavor softened by vanilla ice cream, and the pure joy of dunking cookies into milk—only better. Its universal appeal means everyone from toddlers to grandparents can enjoy it. Plus, it’s endlessly customizable. Want it extra thick like a diner classic or lightened up for fewer calories? No problem. With just a blender and a handful of ingredients, this shake is your shortcut to comfort and smiles. And if you’re into desserts, you’ll love this strawberry cheesecake dump cake or even the banana pudding recipe for more easy indulgences.
How to Make an Oreo Milkshake at Home
Effortless Oreo milkshake recipe for creamy perfection
Craving that creamy, dreamy Oreo milkshake without leaving the house? You’re in luck—it’s as simple as blending a few pantry staples into a glass of pure bliss. Grab two generous scoops (about 2 cups) of classic vanilla ice cream, ½ cup of whole milk, 4–5 Oreo cookies, a dash of vanilla extract, and just a pinch of salt to deepen the cookie flavor. Toss everything into your blender and pulse until smooth but with just enough chunk to feel those signature cookie crumbles.
Pour the blended Oreo milkshake into a tall glass. Then add a generous swirl of whipped cream right on top.
Crumble one extra Oreo and sprinkle it over the whipped cream for texture and crunch.
Want to elevate the look and flavor? Drizzle chocolate syrup inside the glass before pouring—it creates a beautiful marbled effect and adds a touch of decadence.
This simple serving trick turns a quick homemade shake into a dessert that looks as good as it tastes.
This milkshake makes a dreamy follow-up to cozy comfort foods like this Greek garlic chicken or even rich baked goodies like the ultimate Kinder Bueno cookie pie.
Just two ingredients? Yes, you can!
Pressed for time or down to the last few items in your kitchen? You can still enjoy a smooth Oreo milkshake with only two ingredients: Oreo cookies and vanilla ice cream. It’s that easy. Toss five or six Oreos into your blender with about 2 cups of vanilla ice cream, blend until silky, and you’re done. If it’s too thick, let the ice cream soften slightly or add a small splash of milk to help things along. This shortcut still hits all the right notes—sweet, creamy, and indulgently chocolatey—even without the extras.
Want something savory before that shake? Try the juicy chicken thigh recipes or a vibrant plate of blueberry cheesecake cookies for a full flavor contrast.*
Oreo Milkshake vs Chick-fil-A’s Version
Is Chick-fil-A’s Oreo milkshake healthy?
Let’s be honest—nobody orders a milkshake thinking it’s a health food, but if you’re trying to be mindful of ingredients, it helps to know what’s in your cup. Chick-fil-A’s Oreo milkshake, also called the Cookies & Cream milkshake, tastes delicious—but it’s packed with calories, fat, and sugar. A standard small-size serving contains over 600 calories and upwards of 70g of sugar. That’s more than double what you’d get from a homemade version using quality ingredients.
By contrast, when you make your Oreo milkshake at home, you control everything—from the portion size to the sugar content. You can use reduced-fat milk or light ice cream, skip the whipped topping, or even use fewer cookies to cut down on calories. And unlike fast food shakes, which often contain additives or thickeners, your homemade version stays clean, simple, and just as satisfying. Want a healthier treat after dinner? Pair your shake with something lighter like mandarin orange jello salad or even a chilled green bean casserole for a quirky but fun combo.
Why homemade Oreo milkshakes win every time
Aside from the health benefits, homemade Oreo milkshakes win on taste, texture, and customization. You can make yours thicker, frostier, or cookie-heavy—whatever hits the spot. Want to add peanut butter? Toss it in. Prefer almond milk? No problem. Need it dairy-free? Coconut ice cream and plant-based cookies work beautifully. The best part? It takes less than 5 minutes and costs a fraction of what you’d spend at Chick-fil-A or any other fast-food spot.
And if you’re in the mood to experiment, try your shake alongside a slice of hawaiian carrot pineapple cake or switch it up with something rich like this triple chocolate mousse cake—pure dessert heaven.
How Many Oreos Do You Need for a Milkshake?
The ideal Oreo count for maximum flavor
So, how many Oreos should you actually toss into a milkshake? The sweet spot is typically 4 to 6 cookies per two cups of ice cream. This ratio gives you enough cookie crunch and chocolatey flavor without overwhelming the creamy base. If you’re blending for one serving, 3 to 4 Oreos will do the trick. Want a thicker texture? Use more cookies. Prefer a smoother, milkier shake? Drop it to just 2 or 3. The beauty of the Oreo milkshake is how flexible it is. You’re not locked into any rules—just taste and texture.
You can also experiment with flavored Oreos like mint or peanut butter for a fun twist. And if you’re feeling extra, try layering crumbled Oreos in the glass before pouring for visual texture. This kind of versatility makes the Oreo milkshake just as exciting as other homemade sweets like this cheesecake recipe or the ever-satisfying chocolate chip cookie.
Adjusting for texture, sweetness, and servings
Want your shake thicker? Add more ice cream or reduce the milk. Like it thinner and sippable? Increase the milk and blend a little longer. If you’re doubling the batch, simply multiply the base ingredients and toss in a few extra cookies—just don’t overdo it, or you’ll end up with cookie paste instead of a milkshake. If you’re making dessert for guests, consider pre-crushing Oreos and setting them out as a topping bar. It’s interactive and fun.
A quick note: Double Stuf Oreos will intensify sweetness, so balance with extra milk or a pinch of salt. This level of control is what makes homemade so much more satisfying than pre-made versions. For even more flexible dessert ideas, check out this banana pudding or a comforting green bean casserole to round out your meal.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
How do you make an Oreo milkshake?
Blend vanilla ice cream, milk, Oreo cookies, a splash of vanilla extract, and a pinch of salt. Top with whipped cream and crushed cookies for extra flavor and texture.
How to make Oreo milkshake with 2 ingredients?
Just blend vanilla ice cream and Oreo cookies—nothing else! Use about 5 Oreos with 2 cups of ice cream. Optional splash of milk can help thin the consistency if needed.
Is Chick-fil-A Oreo milkshake healthy?
Not really. Chick-fil-A’s Oreo milkshake has over 600 calories and tons of sugar. A homemade shake lets you control the ingredients and reduce excess sugar and additives.
How many Oreos do I need for a milkshake?
Use 4–6 Oreos for a two-cup milkshake. For more intense flavor and crunch, increase the count, or decrease for a lighter blend.
Conclusion
Oreo milkshakes are the kind of treat that brings joy to every sip—no matter the season or setting. Whether you’re going classic with a full-ingredient blend or keeping it simple with just two, there’s no wrong way to make one. Compared to fast food versions, homemade Oreo milkshakes are healthier, tastier, and endlessly adaptable. Best of all, you control everything: the sweetness, the thickness, and the ingredients. From indulgent nights to spontaneous cravings, this milkshake never disappoints.